• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About Todd
  • OVERRUN book website
  • America’s Covert Border War book
  • Awards
  • Book Todd to Speak

Todd Bensman

From Journalism to Counterterrorism Intelligence - and Back.

  • Securing Borders
  • Terrorism & Homeland
  • Todd In the News
  • Congressional Testimony
  • My War In Bosnia Essay

The National Interest magazine: Joe Biden Just Condemned America to More Chinese Espionage — and Worse

July 19, 2021 by Todd Bensman

This entry is part 8 of 11 in the series America's Security Vetting Failures
Series

America's Security Vetting Failures

  • Preventing Espionage and Terrorism: The Real Purpose Behind Trump’s Proposals for Foreign Student and Exchange Visitor Visas
  • Out of Yemen, a Reminder About What May Happen Without “Extreme Vetting” and “Travel Ban” Policies
  • Indictment of Pakistani Doctor H1-B Visa Holder for jihadist plot raises the question: How’s that Vetting Going?
  • A Terror Case the Travel Ban Would Have Prevented
  • Idiot Lights Blinking: Vetting Failures Still Favor Lying Terrorist Migrants
  • New Terrorism Case-In-Point: Why Somalia Is on the Travel Ban List and Must Stay There
  • Creative Destruction Media: One Afghan Military Interpreter Resettled in New Jersey Went Bad; Smuggled fellow Afghan ‘Security Risk’ over the Texas-Mexico Border
  • The National Interest magazine: Joe Biden Just Condemned America to More Chinese Espionage — and Worse
  • An Afghan Vetting Failure
  • An Interview with Bensman, 20 Years After 9/11: Lessons Learned, Improvements Needed
  • 9/11+ 20: America still struggles to vet entering foreigners for national security threats

By Todd Bensman as originally published July 19, 2021 by The National Interest

For nearly two years now, the FBI has nabbed dozens of Chinese Communist Party spies who, while posing as graduate students and research scholars at top academic institutions, siphoned out America’s most cutting edge national defense material for untold years. The spies, many secretly members of China’s military services, had to get in close to do damage this grave and found an unguarded path through America’s largely self-babysitting cultural exchange and student visa programs.

But on the eve of plugging these national security holes, President Joe Biden has canceled the repair and instead bestowed a priceless gift on People’s Liberation Army intelligence services: continued American vulnerability. At issue are the 1.5 million cultural exchange “J” visas and the student “F” visas active in any given recent year. Almost without media notice on July 6, the Biden Department of Homeland Security (DHS) withdrew a September 2020 regulation from the Federal Register that former President Donald Trump’s administration had proposed to relieve the espionage problem and many more besides, like foreign terrorist infiltration and immigration fraud.

All of the arrested Chinese spies used the J and F visas to relieve top American research institutions and their naïve professors of their most sensitive and prized national defense research.

Proposed Rule 2020-20845 was good, apolitical governance that America sorely and obviously needed. It prominently cited the Chinese espionage rampage along with terrorism and immigration fraud for forcing the J and V visa holders of 59 countries to renew them every two or four years, plenty to complete an average graduate degree program or research project. The most valuable part of the process would have had DHS conduct highly useful eyeball-to-eyeball interviews with renewal applicants. The agents also would collect biometric information, spot-check progress at academic institutions, and double-check that originally claimed purposes remained valid going forward.

This periodic regimen would have put the first real basic government oversight on programs whose beneficiaries worldwide always enjoyed open-ended, self-reporting schemes that allowed for indefinite years of visa renewals largely free of close oversight or security vetting opportunities. That system, for instance, allowed the institutions that benefit most from the cheap captive research labor to send word to the U.S. government that they wanted to renew visas. And nothing was in place for government to check when programs justifying the visas ended or changed beyond the originally claimed scope. Visa holders could live for years in the country doing no work or study until they became illegally present.

In short, this was a recipe for regular immigration fraud, espionage, and Islamic terrorism. Perhaps, for instance, a regulation like this one would root out future F-1 visa overstays like country 24-year-old Egyptian Khaled Awad, who stands accused of stabbing Rabbi Shlomo Noginski on July 1 outside his Boston synagogue and was implicated in an earlier anti-Semitic attack on a college roommate.

Discoveries of Khaled Awads would have been possible under the regulation that Biden spiked, which added a useful terrorism screen into the process where trained DHS officers could periodically assess whether student visa holders from countries of terrorism concern, such as Egypt, were keeping their end of the bargain or gave good reason for investigative referrals to the FBI. Keep in mind that F-1 visa holders have far too often committed terrorism crimes in the United States, including a number of the 9/11 hijackers entered on bogus student F visas that enabled plotting.

Khaled Ewad, F-1 student visa holder

Other countries were listed among the 59 based on statistics showing that their citizens most frequently overstay their visas to live illegally in the United States, such as Nigeria, Haiti, Congo, and Cameroon.

The now-dead regulation put all of this simply: “These changes would ensure that the Department has an effective mechanism to periodically and directly assess whether these non-immigrants are complying with the conditions of their classifications and U.S. immigration laws, and to obtain timely and accurate information about the activities they have engaged in and plan to engage in during their temporary stay in the United States.”

What could be so terrible in any of that?

In its explanation, the Biden administration pointed out that 99 percent of those who commented on the regulation – a great many of them likely the affected foreigners, school administrators, and exchange visitor programs – just didn’t want to go through all the bothersome rigmarole for their generous host nation’s security interests, such as showing up for an interview every four years and having to file paperwork. 

The regulation, the opponents most frequently complained, “would significantly burden” them with extra cost and time, would discriminate based on nationality, and would deny them access to “immigration benefits.”

Placed in the context of very real harms of past and present Chinese espionage and foreign student terrorism, rationales like these come off as petty, petulant, selfish, and far from meeting a greater collective national safety need. Although no one in the Biden administration may ever say so out loud, they killed this greater good for perhaps the pettiest reason of all: Donald Trump was the one who proposed it.

That is music to Chinese Communist Party ears.

Series Navigation<< Creative Destruction Media: One Afghan Military Interpreter Resettled in New Jersey Went Bad; Smuggled fellow Afghan ‘Security Risk’ over the Texas-Mexico BorderAn Afghan Vetting Failure >>

Filed Under: Terrorism and Homeland Security

Subscribe to Mailing List

Subscribing to my list will entitle subscribers to be alerted to blog posts, articles and writings as they are published, as well as any special announcements.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Bensman’s Newsletter

Sign Up

Bensman’s Books

Cover of America's Covert Boarder War book Cover of Overrun Book

Follow Me Online

Find Bensman on LinkedIn Find Bensman on Twitter Find Bensman on Gettr Find Bensman on Truth Social

Related Posts

Every Last One: Another Prosecution of the Garland, Texas Terror Attack Starts Next Month
CBP Removes Press Release About Migrants on the U.S. Terror Watch List Who Crossed the Southern Border
TUNE IN: C-Span 2’s Book TV: America’s Covert Border War
The Hero Texas Cop Who Killed Two ISIS Terrorists Mid-Attack
Part I Townhall Series: A New Terror Travel Tactic is Born
Homeland Security Today: State of Border Counterterrorism
A Federal Judge’s Bizarre Views of Justice for American ISIS Terrorist and the Bereaved Mother of His Victim
Why Iran’s Cash Crunch Hasn’t Disabled Hezbollah
Guatemala’s Terrorist Designation of Hizballah Explained
Review of America’s Covert Border War book (Townhall Media)

© 2023 · Todd Bensman · Site By WP Attendant